Hole-in-the-Wall Gangs Revisited

Clavin, Tom.  Bandit Heaven: The Hole-in-the Wall Gangs and the Final Chapter of the Wild West.  

          New York: St. Martin's Press, 2024.  ISBN: 9781250282408

The Wild West!  Cowboys and Indians!  Rustlers and train robbers!  All the stuff of Hollywood movies, right?  Well maybe, but often not.  As Tom Clavin illustrates so well in Bandit Heaven,  Hollywood got a lot wrong when screen writers and directors take history and put it on the big screen, particularly in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969).  So to get a glimpse behind the tinsel, dive in with Tom Clavin.

 

Tom Clavin opens the book with an 1899 Wild Bunch train robbery, laying out how it was planned and how it occurred in the Prologue.  The book itself is laid out in three acts.  Act I - Heaven on Earth - provides the background and setting for Brown's Hole, Hole-in-th-Wall, and Robbers Roost and the early outlaws.  The reader learns about the cattle and horse rustling business and the conflict between cattle barons and homesteaders and sheep herders.  Act II - Leader of the Pack - introduces Robert Leroy Parker born on April 13, 1866, a Friday, to British Mormon immigrants in Utah.  He grew up working with livestock and drifted into rustling and the outlaw life where he later acquired the nickname Butch Cassidy.  He was joined on the outlaw trail by Elzy Lay, an Ohio boy, Harry Alonzo Longabaugh, from Pennsylvania, who became the Sundance Kid, and Harvey Alexander Logan from Iowa, also know as "Kid Curry."  Then there the women like Ethel Place and the sisters Josie and Ann Bassett who sometimes accompanied the gang.  Act III - The Lawman Trail - discusses the strange evolution of law in the west and the role of vigilantism and the Pinkerton Detective Agency.  These chapters also highlight individuals such as Charlie Siringo, Joseph Shelby LeFors, John T. Pope, and others who chased outlaws, infiltrated union organizations, solved murders, and brought in fugitives from justice.  Act IV - Fall From Heaven - covers the end of the outlaw life.  As more folks settled the West and telegraphs spread alongside the railroads, it became harder for outlaws to disappear after a robbery.  Bank note numbers would be circulated around the country and folks were getting nabbed in strange locations when they tried to spend their ill-gotten gains.  Also, the bandits did themselves no favors when a group visited Fort Worth (TX) for a wedding and had a group photo taken which got used as advertising by the store.  That photo would lead to the arrest and or death of a number of the Wild Bunch.  This slow closing of the noose led Butch Cassidy, Sundance Kid and Ethel Place to move way south to Argentina where they managed to set up a ranch until their past and old ways caught up with them and closed the book on some of the most famous outlaws of the Wild West.

 

So if you have an interest in the "true" Wild West of outlaws and rustlers, pick up Tom Clavin's Bandit Heaven and indulge yourself.  You will not regret it!